Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Vote by midnight March 9 for Burger Brackets

Remember:

  • You are voting (by midnight Wednesday) to add two places to the lineup of 14 listed below. So only comments about places NOT already in the 14 will be counted. (You'll get to vote on matchups beginning Friday, and votes will be part -- not all -- of how we decide winners.)
  • Anonymous comments don't count. (I'm posting them because I'm trying to wean us slowly off the anonymous thing here, but will NOT count them -- so if you "voted" with an anonymous comment, go back, get a sign-in and vote so it will count! More on anonymous posting in general to come.)
  • No chains with locations outside the Carolinas.
The 14 already in are:
Brooks.
Big Daddy's Burger Bar.
Zack's.
Mueller's.
Pinky's.
Comet Grill.

The Liberty.
Jake's Good Eats.
Lulu.
Hinson's Drive-In.
Snoops Grill.
Savor Cafe.
Eddie's Place.
Lebowski's Neighborhood Grill.

So: Did your fave not make it? Comment on this, and the two top ones will be added to the bracket of 16. Have at it!

We'll announce the full bracket of 16, including pairings, in this Friday's CLT section.

The above 14 are in no particular order, and the order has nothing to do with eventual pairings.

Trying to remember prior year's brackets and results? Let me help!
The 2010 Fries final story is here and the bracket is here. (Use control + to zoom it bigger if you can't read it.)
The 2009 Pizza final results are here and the bracket is here.
And the 2008 Wings final wrapup is here and the bracket is here.

343 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 343 of 343   Newer›   Newest»
Anonymous said...

The Lodge, in the shopping complex of Colony and Rea

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Unknown said...

The new Maxwell's Tavern in downtown Waxhaw, NC makes an EXCELLENT Burger!!! They grind their own beef so you can get a Rare or Medium Rare burger! We love their burgers!

Unknown said...

Big Daddy's Burger Bar

Brannon said...

Any serious carnivore would have to put Crepe Cellar at the top of their list. Hands down...best burger in Charlotte.

Judy said...

Topz is my first choice! Love their turkey burger.

Charles F. said...

Topz - healthier and delicious!

Kate said...

Can't believe The Burger Company is not on here. By far the best burger in town.

Unknown said...

The Diamond! And does everyone who is writing in about the Penguin realize that it's not. the. same. burger. If you have been there in the past few months, then you are up-to-date, but otherwise? That bureger you remember is only a memory.

Holden said...

The Crepe Cellar? Really? Are we talking Burgers or pancakes?

Anonymous said...

Mr. K's must be on this list. I repeat ... MUST BE ON THIS LIST:)

Dave said...

Another vote for BT's Burgerjoint in Rivergate. A hidden gem for sure.

Mike Anderson said...

Growler's Pourhouse and Flatiron Kitchen & Taphouse. Both amazing.

Angel said...

I vote for Topz!

Crystal said...

Rusty's Deli & Grille - Park Rd. in Quail Corners Shopping Center.

Unknown said...

Cowfish in southpark!!

Unknown said...

Cowfish! Cowfish! Cowfish!

Anonymous said...

COOKOUT!!!

Jaime said...

The Burger Company and Sammy's in Belmont.

Mike D said...

Big Daddy's!!

Dee said...

I think Big Daddy's is the best!

Gordy said...

Delicious burgers are found at the Crepe Cellar in NODA!

Maggi said...

The Cowfish! The Cowfish!! The Cowfish!

Johnny W said...

East Blvd. Bar & Grill!

john said...

BT's Burger joint hands down best in the Queen City

kate said...

burger company! can't believe it is not already in the running! by far the best burger in charlotte, and without a doubt the best burger on that block!

Andy said...

Kyle Fletcher's BBQ in Gastonia, BBQ joint but their burgers are the best in Gaston County.

Kelly S. said...

Pinky's

Unknown said...

the new wagyu burger at Mimosa is my new fave! with the big easy steak sauce and the ham and swiss makes it an original among burgers!

fQ said...

To echo a few others, Mr K's on South .. it's a Charlotte institution .. has to be on this list!

Ultraviolet said...

Another vote for TOPZ!

Unknown said...

The Cowfish has amazing burgers. Lots of usual yummy combinations, some crazy yummy concoctions and the opportunity to have it anyway you like it! These burgers are pure beef, perfectly cooked and dripping with goodness. Please don't overlook them, they are top 16 material for sure.......I could eat their burgers every day!

Unknown said...

Mr K's burgers are delish and very reasonably priced! They should be on the list!!!

ben said...

SOUTH 21!!

Rolf Loken said...

Big Daddy's gets my vote. Love the "Sam I Am" burger with a fried egg on it!

Russell said...

Providence Road Sundries with new Chef, Ownership & Management has the best burgers!

Zack said...

The Burger Company should definitely be in the bracket. They're always busy and burgers are great. Can't believe they aren't in there already!

Unknown said...

BELLE ACRES on South Blvd!!!!!! I've been a member since I was 7yrs. old and still get the burger every Friday!! The fresh cut fries are a bonus.

The journey goes on said...

The Penguin. And don't forget the fried pickles on the side!

stufunee said...

the Burger co. has to be on this list.

Ecuchick said...

Mr K's should be on the list

Mark Rich said...

Jackalope Jacks is by far the best burgers in Charlotte!

Gavin said...

Whaaat? The Burger Company! Go ahead and add em to the list!

trista said...

The Burger Co. Pimento Burger...best in town

Monica said...

Rusty's Deli & Grille - Park Rd. in Quail Corners Shopping Center.



.

Glenn Hunt said...

BT's Bugerjoint, without a doubt, an awesome burger....

Anonymous said...

Jackalope Jacks

Unknown said...

JACKALOPE JACK'S GREAT BURGERS AND GREAT PEOPLE!

Unknown said...

The Penguin Rocks. Yea, say what you want about the much talked about changeover, but the burgers rock, succulent, fast and unique combinations make the grade above and beyond any of the others listed. Whats best is that since the changeover, the staff is personable not snotty like before and its actually clean, unlike before. So cheers Penguin, you got my vote!

chris said...

Jackalope Jacks

Mrs.C said...

The Burger Company!!!!

Ryleigh said...

The Burger Company has the best burgers. Done.

Anonymous said...

How about Jackalope Jacks? I'm a Charlotte newbie who really loves to eat. I think their food is about the best "bar food" I've had, but I keep going back to their burgers. consistency always wins, and their burgers are consistently very good.

Anonymous said...

Jackalope Jacks!!!!

Michael B. said...

Hinson's Drive-In! Phil and Leslie make the best burgers!!

D said...

Killington's Pub burger is a definite!

WBH said...

COWFISH!!

Unknown said...

CowFish!!!

Dharmamama said...

The Diamond, hands down!!

Unknown said...

By Far....BBQ King..I have been going there since I was 4 or 5 and I love it

Barker said...

Mimosa Grill? Must be staff members voting! Penguin is past tense... Burger Company or South 21 (classic!) for sure.

Aaron W. Ligon said...

Cowfish. No contest

Unknown said...

Comet Grill HANDS DOWN!

Cynthia Lawing said...

I can't believe the Burger Company isn't on here! The many different burgers are tops, the chicken sandwich is awesome...so many different cheeses, not to mention sweet potato fries and fried pickles. Now I think I need a fix!!

Chris said...

Crepe Cellar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cynthia said...

BT Burgers - I have eaten there several times and never had a bad burger. Lots of topping to choose from also.

Anonymous said...

Fran's needs to be on the list!

Stephanie said...

TOPZ has amazing burgers. They are grilled not fried, and they have turkey burgers as well as beef. They should definitely be on the list of the best.-

charlesh said...

I've not visited over half the places on this list but of theones I've been to Brooks is hands down the best.

Christa said...

The Crepe Cellar only offers one type of burger and it is pure bliss, with gruyere, onion straws and aioli!!!!! Oh, and the fries!!! MMMMMmmmmmmm

growlprowl said...

Lupie's!!!

Anonymous said...

Don't forget Topz! They are the best.

Anonymous said...

Zack's

Roger said...

Please add Topz

Anonymous said...

Brooks all the way. Everthing else is trash.

Anonymous said...

So glad to see that Fran's is not on the list... sorry, but i have had numerous bad experiences there and was beginning to think that money was changing hands the way they have been featured so frequently and positively in the Observer. (Said very tongue in cheek.)

Glad to see Comet and Liberty made the cut... there burgers are fantastic!

Chuck said...

Lupies has set the standard for a great burger for years.

Anonymous said...

BBQ King on Wilkinson!

bk said...

The penguin definetly. While known for other tasty meals, 131 main has a GREAT burger.

Anonymous said...

My house........ stuff with Blue Cheese...indent cent of burger, liberally salt and pepper. Sear on high heat 1 minute. Flip 3 minutes.......cook 3 minutes.....Turn off flame place bacon on top...half a slice of provolone and half a slice of white american.......Place butter on buns place down on grill let rest for 3 minutes with cover down. Open and Bestill the beauty!!

Unknown said...

The only thing better than Growler's Solid Gold Mondays is the burger next door at CREPE CELLAR. Eat it. It's great.

DD said...

The Comet & Mr. K's !!

crazyjer said...

Nix

crazyjer said...

Penguin

Unknown said...

Mimosa grill has by far the best Burger in Charlotte it us juicy and full of flavor and I don't eat burgers that often but I always get one when I go to Mimosa Grill. So delicious!!

Unknown said...

BURGER COMPANY!!!!! The best intown and for sure the Westside!

Anonymous said...

Fran's filling station

Colt 45 said...

Mattie's Diner...come get some!

Susan Says said...

Oh yeah... BT's Burgerjoint has the BEST Bacon Burger EVER!!!! Yummy!

ArtShots said...

TOPZ.....

Josh said...

Jackalope Jacks has great burgers!! Service is great as well!

Anonymous said...

Crepe Cellar by far!

Anonymous said...

I vote Topz!!

Unknown said...

McDonalds

Anonymous said...

CREPE CELLAR.

BOMB DIGGITY

Unknown said...

Duane says: Crepe Cellar has the bestest burgers!!

ushue2 said...

I think the Penquin and The Diamond are too "new" for this competition, but Lupie's should be added.

Anonymous said...

Crossroads Grill in Indian Trail!

Dolla Bill said...

TOPZ!!!

Anonymous said...

"Eat Here Now"

The town of Ayrsley - I-485 & S. Tryon

Jennifer said...

Liberty!

Unknown said...

Mimosa Grill has the best burger in the city. The aioli and grilled red onions together may be one of the best things I have ever put in my mouth. Great job Chef Fortes!

Scott said...

Crepe Cellar should be on the list for sure.

Unknown said...

CREPE CELLAR!

Unknown said...

Had a burger at Mimosa Grill the other day and it's the best I've had in Charlotte!! Kudos to the chef!!

Unknown said...

Crepe Cellar Burger all the way!!!

Unknown said...

Topz, Topz, Topz. The very best burger!

RayRay said...

Toast in Davidson...a must for burger lovers!

Unknown said...

Crepe Celler Burger Please!!! A must on this list!! The BEST hands down!

Unknown said...

Crepe Cellar is Stellar!

Anonymous said...

R.o's barbecue in Gastonia is the best!

Frank said...

DIAMOND DIAMOND DIAMOND!!

Presh said...

The Diamond ROCKS!!

Anonymous said...

Mimosa Grill has a Kobe Burger that is out of this world!! Roasted mushrooms,ham and swiss cheese!!!!! And it's soooo juicy!!! Unbelievable...

Laurie smith said...

Bt's burgerjoint - need one closer to town. Also like firebirds burgers

Sheila N. said...

Burger Co. on Morehead. They are the best!!!!

Scott S. said...

A buddy and I have been on the quest for the perfect burger in charlotte for the past several years. Yes, many burgers mentioned are really good...

The most unexpected place though tops the list... The Crepe Cellar in NoDa has by far the best burger in Charlotte. Not only that, but their fries are really good too (for some reason this is tough to find in this town).

I put a little adaptation on mine; hold the aioli, add bacon and cooked medium rare (they always overcook)

If you want medium, ask for med rare
if you want med rare, ask for rare
if you want med well to well, go somewhere else, because the burger is not good overcooked.

Paxton said...

Definitely the 15 dollar burger on lunch menu at the palm - for the normal person gotta go with Bt's.

Carl said...

The Lodge on Colony Road.

ian said...

BT's Burgerjoint in the Rivergate shopping center has the best burgers around!!!!!

Anonymous said...

The Cowfish!

Unknown said...

The burger at Mimosa was GRRRREAT!!

Unknown said...

The crepe cellar has one fine burger.

Anonymous said...

South 21s Super Boy is my favorite. A little slaw, some chili, mustard and onions. It's the tops for me...........

Ashley said...

The Burger Company!!! Most definitely...they have THE BEST burgers in Charlotte. They GRIND THEIR OWN MEAT! It doesn't get much better than that. It is good quality meat and the burgers are juicy and they have stuffed ones too!

RodT said...

Casting my votes for Lupie's and the Penguin.

LAS said...

The Burger Co on W. Morehead is great! Unique burgers and sides! The quality is the best!

May Johnston said...

I know Pinky's Westside Grill is already "in", but I'm late to the table (Ha!) and just have to say I had the White Trash Burger there last Saturday and it is the BEST!!! Can't wait to go back & order it again -- it is an AWESOME burger!!

Unknown said...

When I'm in Charlotte, it's Big Daddy's Burger Bar for me.

Unknown said...

Crepe Cellar plz!

jacky said...

The burger company is great

William said...

The new Bonfire Bar and Grill in Indian Trail has a great burger.

still a panther fan said...

Ok so out of the 14 maybe 5 are great. The Burger Company should be in the mix for sure. Make it a real competition!

Anonymous said...

Dukes in Monroe....you gotta go.

George said...

Love TOPZ

Anonymous said...

THE SODA SHOP IN DAVIDSON!!!

discourser said...

A contest for Charlotte's best burger would be quite remiss without the iconic Mr. K.'s on the list.

Aaron said...

I stay in Steele Creek and I'm a fan of BT's Burger Joint however if we're talking best I'd say Cowfish.

Anonymous said...

Matties and South 21!!!

Anonymous said...

Good call on crepe cellar. All their food is solid.

Slowshutter said...

Alexander Michael's hands down.

Vince J said...

NIX...or as my little nephew says...the Flaming Burger

Unknown said...

The fact that places where you can't get a medium rare burger are even on this list is ridiculous. The penguin is a good DINER burger but when compared to a real burger like Lulu's, its not a competition. Its like a high-school basketball team playing a professional team.

Lulu's and the Liberty are the only real players on this list. My vote is Lulu's.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 343 of 343   Newer› Newest»